MP3, M4A, WAV or FLAC: picking an audio format
Four extensions, two ideas: either the file threw some sound away to get smaller, or it did not.
Lossy and lossless
MP3 and M4A are lossy: they discard parts of the signal most people cannot hear, and the file gets dramatically smaller. WAV and FLAC are lossless: every sample survives, and the file is five to ten times bigger.
The catch with lossy audio is that the discarding is permanent. Converting a 128 kbps MP3 to FLAC does not restore anything; it just wraps the damage in a bigger file.
What bitrate buys you
| Bitrate | Roughly per minute | Sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| 128 kbps | ~1 MB | Fine on phone speakers, thin on good headphones |
| 192 kbps | ~1.4 MB | The sensible middle for most listening |
| 320 kbps | ~2.4 MB | Hard to tell from the source on normal gear |
| Lossless | ~10 MB (FLAC) | Identical to the source, by definition |
Above 320 kbps, lossy formats stop paying for themselves: you add megabytes for differences most listeners cannot pick out in a blind test.
Pick by what you are doing
- Music on a phone → MP3 320 kbps or M4A. M4A (AAC) sounds slightly better at the same size and is the native format on Apple devices.
- Podcasts and talks → MP3 128–192 kbps. Speech does not need more.
- Editing, sampling, mastering → WAV. Uncompressed, instant to seek, universally accepted by editors.
- Archiving a collection → FLAC. Lossless like WAV but roughly half the size.